EVE-RHESSI DEM Models and the Low-energy Cutoff for Nonthermal Electrons
From RHESSI Wiki
|1st Author:||Jim McTiernan|
|Published:||9 September 2019|
|Next Nugget:||Moreton wave|
|Previous Nugget:||Stealth Coronal Mass Ejections from Active Regions|
Solar flares consist of hot plasmas with a complicated distribution of temperatures as they evolve, heating and cooling different magnetic structures. We characterize this distribution on a given line of sight, or in total, as the differential quantity (DEM), essentially d(n^V)/dT. The DEM is a measure of how much plasma exists in a source as a function of temperature, weighted by the square of the electron density. Even at the highest spatial resolution (the smallest possible image pixel) we still expect a distribution of temperatures simply because the line of sight passes through an optically thin medium, as observed in X-rays.
RHESSI, an X-ray imaging instrument, and EVE , an EUV spectrometer, can be used in combination to obtain the solar flare Differential Emission Measure (DEM) from about 2 to 50 MK. (Ref. 1). Figure 1 shows an example. The left hand plot shows a measurement for a single time interval during a solar flare of 13 February 2011 (SOL2011-02-13T17:28 - GOES class M6.6). In the plot, the black curve is the DEM calculated using EVE data only, the red curve is the DEM calculated using RHESSI data, and the blue curve is the DEM which is fit to both instruments simultaneously. The right hand plot shows the same curves for multiple time intervals during two flares, the 2011 February 2013 flare and a flare two days later, SOL2011-02-15T01L44 (GOES class X2.2). The curves are normalized to remove time variation. From the plots, it is clear that the combined DEM follows the EVE DEM at low temperature (less than 10 MK or Log(T) = 7) and it follows the RHESSI DEM above 10 MK. The high T component (40 MK, Log(T)=7.6) that often appears in the EVE-only solutions is suppressed when RHESSI is included, and the low T component (5 MK, Log(T)=6.7) for RHESSI-only, which does not reflect reality, is likewise suppressed when EVE is included.
In a recent paper, (Ref.2) the combined EVE-RHESSI DEM was used to help estimate the elusive low-energy cutoff for nonthermal electrons. In this work the cutoff energy is related to the energy at which the presence of thermal emission forces any nonthermal spectrum to have a sharp downwards break. The concept is illustrated in Figure 2, which is a model of a typical RHESSI spectrum. For low energies, 5 to 10 keV, the emission is dominated by bremsstrahlung emission from hot plasma (aka the "thermal component"). At higher energies above 30 keV, the emission is (presumably) bremsstrahlung from accelerated electrons ("nonthermal component"). In between, both kinds of emission may exist. If we extend the nonthermal line from high energy back to 0 keV, then there would be an infinite amount of energy in the nonthermal, so there must be a minimum or "cutoff" energy for those electrons. (Ref. 3) In the Figure, the cutoff energy is 10 keV. This cutoff is an important parameter when calculating the energy content in nonthermal electrons. It is, however, obscured by the thermal component. For the best estimate of the cutoff, the thermal component needs to be accounted for as accurately as possible. The DEM calculation gives a better approximation for the thermal emission than the single temperature, or isothermal, approximation that is often used in this sort of calculation.
Typically, the amount of thermal emission relative to nonthermal emission increases during flares, so the calculations were done during the first two minutes of each flare in the sample. There were 38 flares in the sample, and 61 time intervals from those flares were investigated.
It turns out that the estimate of cutoff energy depends critically on the ratio of flux in the 6-7 keV Fe line complex (shown in Figure 2) to the continuum emission in the 10 to 20 keV range. This ratio is sensitive to temperature; for the combined DEM, the need to fit EVE data in addition to RHESSI data results in a DEM which has a much lower average temperature (of order 10-12 MK) than would be obtained using RHESSI alone (roughly 20 to 25 MK). For most of the time intervals, the amount of emission seen by RHESSI in the Fe line complex and the relatively low temperature limits the allowable amount of thermal continuum emission and requires a substantial amount of nonthermal emission in the 10 to 20 keV range, resulting in a cutoff energy less than 10 keV.
Since the Fe line complex to 10 to 20 keV continuum ratio is important, it is neccessary to consider the effect of the relative abundances of the elements on the X-ray spectra, in particular regarding that of Fe. Figure 3 shows chi-squared curves for a time interval early in the 2011 February 13 flare. The black curve shows chi-squared as a function of cutoff energy for the model with "coronal" relative abundance, with the abundance of Fe a factor of four times the abundance in the photosphere. (Ref. 4) Coronal abundance is used as the default for most RHESSI analysis. The red curve shows chi-squared for the photospheric abundance model. Why the difference between the different abundance values? It turns out that the Fe line to continuum ratio constraint is more relaxed for the photospheric abundance models. For a given temperature and emission measure, reducing the Fe abundance by a factor of four to photospheric levels reduces the flux in the Fe line complex by a factor of approximately four, but only reduces the continuum emission by a factor of two, reducing the ratio of Fe line to continuum emission by a factor of two. Thus for photospheric abundance a given amount of Fe line emission is consistent with twice as much 10 to 20 keV continuum emission as for coronal abundance. This allows for a higher cutoff energy. For the sample of 61 time intervals from 38 different flares, it was found that for coronal abundance, most (39) values of the cutoff energy were less than 10 keV, and for photospheric abundance, cutoffs were mostly in the 15 to 25 keV range.
1) EVE-RHESSI DEM models can fit data for both instruments simultaneously and give useful constraints for the low energy cutoff for nonthermal emission early in solar flares.
2) For coronal abundance, the cutoff energy is typically low (less than 10 keV), and is limited by the relatively low average temperature of the combined EVE-RHESSI DEM, and the high Fe abundance.
3) For photospheric abundance, the cutoff energy is typically approximately 10 keV higher than for coronal abundance.
1. "Constraining Solar Flare Differential Emission Measures with EVE and RHESSI" A. Caspi, J. McTiernan & H. Warren
2. "The Multi-instrument (EVE-RHESSI) DEM for Solar Flares, and Implications for Nonthermal Emission" J. McTiernan, A. Caspi & H. Warren
4. "The Potential for Plasma Diagnostics from Stellar Extreme-Ultraviolet Observations" U. Feldman et.al.