A Shocking Type II

From RHESSI Wiki

Revision as of 20:52, 28 April 2012 by Hazelbain (Talk | contribs)
Jump to: navigation, search

Number: 174
1st Author: Hazel Bain
2nd Author: Sam Krucker and Lindsay Glesener
Published: 30 April 2012
Next Nugget: TBD
Previous Nugget: RHESSI and IRIS [1]
List all



Historically radio bursts were given the nomenclature of type I, type II, type II and so on as a way of distinguishing their different characteristics. Type II bursts were defined as slow drifting features in radio spectrogram data. At interplanetary distances it is generally accepted that type II bursts are the result of electron acceleration in the foreshock of a propagating CME (Bale et al. 1999 1). However at coronal heights we’re still not sure what mechanism generates the shock that accelerates the electrons: a flare-related blast wave (Vrsnak et al. 2006 2) or a CME (or small-scale ejecta) propagating faster than the local fast magnetosonic speed (Dauphin et al. 2006 3). In the later scenario the shock can form as piston-driven shock or a bow shock (Vrsnak 2005 4). For a bow shock, the ambient plasma is able to flow around the driver. The shock is situated at the forehead of the driver such that both shock and driver propagate at the same speed. In the case of a piston-driven shock the ambient plasma the plasma is unable to flow behind the driver. In this case the shock moves faster than the driver and the standoff distance between the two increases over time. Without radio imaging and an accurate model for the coronal electron density, it is difficult to determine how the type II and propagating shock are related.

3rd of November 2010

Figure 1: Type II radio burst observed by PHOENIX (175-600 MHz) and HUMAIN (45-175 MHz) radio spectrogram data. NRH observing frequencies are marked. Vertical lines show time intervals used for fitting.

Type II’s occurring in the frequency range (150-445 MHz) of the Nancay Radioheliograph (NRH), which is capable of imaging, are infrequent. However on the 3rd of November 2010, an erupting plasmoid with an associated metric type II radio burst (Figure 1), was observed by AIA and NRH. Figure 2 shows a composite difference image of AIA 131 A (blue) and 335 A (red). Multiwavelength analysis (Glesener et al. 2012 in preparation) shows a hot core consisting of ~11 MK plasma, surrounded by a cooler envelope of plasma around a few MK. Plotted asterisks show the location of the type II radio burst at NRH 270, 298 and 327 MHz for the time of the AIA image. Figure 2 also shows two RHESSI X-ray sources. Since the flare is occulted by around 6 degrees, the compact source (blue) close to the limb is situated at the tip of the flaring loops, while an extended source (red) is observed high in the corona, (see this earlier nugget and Glesener et. al 2012 in preparation).

Figure 2: Composite difference image of AIA 131 A (blue) and 335 A (red). Asterisks show the location of the type II burst at NRH 270, 298 and 327 MHz. Red and blue contours show RHESSI X-ray emission.

Fastest off the mark: the plasmoid or the type II?

The propagation speed of the shock and the drop off in the coronal electron density dictate the frequency drift rate of the type II. Using a combination of NRH and LASCO C2 polarized brightness images (Gopalswamy & Yashiro 2011 5), we are able to fine-tune and normalize an appropriate density model and then fit the type II burst to determine the speed of the progenitor shock. For a constant acceleration model the shock was found to be traveling with a velocity of ~1960 km/s (with a deceleration of -4 km/s/s). Tracking the leading edge of the plasmoid in AIA images at 131, 335, 211 and 193 A, we found propagation speeds of 670 km/s, 740 km/s, 1150 km/s and 1440 km/s respectively, showing that the envelope of cooler plasma is moving faster than the hot core.


Unfortunately, since the flare is occulted and images from STEREO B are saturated and have insufficient cadence, we were unable to investigate the flare-related energy release. Therefore conclusively ruling out a blast wave is not possible. However, the observations have shown that the shock, outlined by the type II radio burst, is moving faster than the erupting plasmoid. This, and the location of the type II burst ahead of the plasmoid (and also the presence of a whopping great plasmoid in general) are indicative of a piston-driven shock.


Facts about A Shocking Type IIRDF feed
RHESSI Nugget Date30 April 2012  +
RHESSI Nugget First AuthorHazel Bain  +
RHESSI Nugget Index174  +
RHESSI Nugget Second AuthorSam Krucker and Lindsay Glesener  +
Personal tools