CMEless Flares

From RHESSI Wiki

CMEless Flares
Number:	107
1st Author:	Hugh Hudson
2nd Author:	Säm Krucker
Published:	10 August 2009
Next Nugget:	NUGGET 108
Previous Nugget:	Where are the flares
List all

Contents 1 Introduction 2 Hard X-rays 3 Soft X-rays 4 Conclusion

Introduction

Solar flares are much more common than coronal mass ejections (CMEs). Nevertheless the standard model for a solar flare essentially requires the prior or simultaneous occurrence of a CME. How do we reconcile this discrepancy? A comparison of flare properties, for flares with and without CMEs, would seem like an obvious place to start. In this Nugget we tackle this question as regards the X-ray properties, basing our study on recent lists of powerful (hence easy-to-study) major flares without CMEs. These "confined" flares comprise about 10% of all of the X-class flares and have recognizable magnetic properties that point to the flare's magnetic environment as a key factor (reference [1]). The particular flares that we study happen to be [GOES X-class] events, which are the most energetic ones; it turns out that beyond this level essentially all flares have CMEs. We could also study weaker events without CMEs but it is more fun to concentrate on the 13 extreme events tabulated by Nat Gopalswamy and his collaborators.

Hard X-rays

Hard X-rays definitively mark the [impulsive phase] of a solar flare, the time of most intense energy release. Thanks to improvements in the data, we now can confidently say that this is the time of the fastest acceleration of the CME associated with the flare, if there is one. It is therefore natural to identify the impulsive phase with the drastic readjustments of the solar magnetic field that cause everything. An earlier Nugget has described the "soft-hard-soft" pattern of hard X-ray development that characterizes this phase of a flare.

It turns out that there is a different morphology, often seen in the most energetic events: that of the soft-hard-harder spectral development. Somewhat to our surprise, we have found that we don't see this pattern at all in the CMEless events of our sample. The morphology is entirely the standard soft-hard-soft pattern. It has been known for some time that "extended" events with this hard X-ray spectral property correlate well with solar energetic particles (SEPs), a CME-related phenomenon that is a part of [space weather].

Soft X-rays

Do these CMEless events also look different in soft X-rays? The answer to this is "yes" in two ways: first, they do not show the long-duration [LDE] property that was one of the original motivations for the standard model. Second, they may not show obvious "precursors" - gradual increases often interpreted as pre-heating prior to a flare.

Conclusion

[1] Wang & Zhang, 2007